This post is from a suggested group
SP 15 Moon Phase Clock #d printed
I printed the smaller version of the Moon Phase clock.and with a few difficulties got it running well (getting the weight shell weight right was one of them). It ran for about 3 months reasonable accurately. THEN it stopped working and I spent days an days diagnosing an reprinting certain parts to no avail. I must have taken the clock apart so many times I lost count. It would run for a few seconds and then stop. I though maybe the cord for the weight was tangled so rewound it several times to make sure it wound on smoothly but again no luck. By this time I was ready to box it up and write it off as unsolvable. Until I had one last thought - reprint the escape wheel - so I did and straight away the clock started working again with excellent amplitude which tells me ethat PLA…




I am curious what symptoms you were experiencing that made you want to reprint the escapment? And what changed after the new one was installed? Was the escapement sluggish? Did it show any signs of wear?
My experience is that PLA works great for many years. Here is a picture of the escapement from a clock that ran continuously for at least 6 years. It still runs perfectly, but has been retired because of wall space. There is no visible wear and only the slightest amount of dust on a few touching surfaces. I have no idea what the filament brand is. It was printed in 2017 or 2018.
The escapement is extremely lightly loaded. Even though the surfaces rub, there is very little wear. This is also true for classic style brass clocks that run for hundreds of years.
I typically print gears in generic silk PLA. My latest clocks use Eryone dual color red/blue silk PLA. It was selected based on price at around US$17 per kg on Amazon. Many other brands appear to have similar results. I have never seen PLA wear out. Of course, some modifiers like marble texture, wood fill, or carbon fiber should be avoided for the gears.
My experience between brands is that some filament is slippery and some is sticky. You could try the friction test at https://www.myminifactory.com/object/3d-print-clock-gear-friction-test-836333 to see if your filament is sticky.